SYNOPSIS Our project is an allegorical story comparing the political systems of Singapore and America. Singapore is considered a ‘false’ democracy, whereas America is a ‘true’ democracy. We would like to suggest in our project that ‘true’ democracy is not necessarily better than ‘false’ democracy.
In our story, a group of people, trapped in a cave with no light, have developed an enhanced sense of hearing. Singing together gives them purpose, and they are led by an elder and a group of elite singers in perfect harmony—the highlight of their existence. When Outsiders break into the cave, the protagonist leaves, as he had resented his restrictive life there. He also brings his sister along. The Outsiders sing, too. Yet, because they are bent on singing their own tune and each clamours to be heard over the others, their cacophony of voices creates a chaotic and messy environment. The protagonist realises that sight and ‘freedom to sing whatever he wants’ wasn’t all he thought it was. Upon learning that the Outsiders plan to make the Cave into a tourist attraction, he rushes back but is too late.
We parallel the society in the Cave with Singapore, where the government makes most of the decisions and lead the people towards progress as they see it. America is compared to the Outside world, where there is freedom of speech and many opinions voiced at the same time, mirroring the freedom of democracy. While Singapore’s way of governance is often viewed as restrictive, the strict laws help to make Singapore successful, safe and peaceful. In our story, the lack of sight allows the people a keener sense of hearing, and thus more harmonious singing, which is the essence of their living.
This story will be made into an audio iBook, to accentuate the ‘lack of sight’ which is featured in the story.
Thursday, July 19, 2012
Wednesday, July 4, 2012
Final product: Key features
Audio book
An audio book would allow listeners to be immersed into the strange new environment in the story, particularly to experience a world in the same way as the cave dwellers do: through their sense of hearing.
Difference in semantics
Use of different semantics to reflect the effect of a change in environment on language
This is due to two reasons. Firstly, this is a logical change since language is based on experiences, so a different environment changes the scope of vocabulary used. For example, Yyou would expect a blind civilization to say “I hear what you mean” rather than “I see what you mean”. Furthermore, these changes can immerse the listener into the strange new environment of the sightless cave.
Contains hand drawn pictures.
These pictures will be shown from increasing brightness. This is to allow listeners to experience the characters’ increasing ability to see; which parallels how their “view” of the world changes
An audio book would allow listeners to be immersed into the strange new environment in the story, particularly to experience a world in the same way as the cave dwellers do: through their sense of hearing.
Difference in semantics
Use of different semantics to reflect the effect of a change in environment on language
This is due to two reasons. Firstly, this is a logical change since language is based on experiences, so a different environment changes the scope of vocabulary used. For example, Yyou would expect a blind civilization to say “I hear what you mean” rather than “I see what you mean”. Furthermore, these changes can immerse the listener into the strange new environment of the sightless cave.
Contains hand drawn pictures.
These pictures will be shown from increasing brightness. This is to allow listeners to experience the characters’ increasing ability to see; which parallels how their “view” of the world changes
Background information
Background
We have noticed that many believe in the superiority of democracy as a political model. However, with "managed democracies" such as China slowly dominating the international scene, we have come to realize that managed democracies may prove to be a superior political model
Objectives
Showcase ideal democracy from another perspective, particularly to highlight its flaws
Decisions are only as good as the people who make them; a small group of elites can make decisions better than a large group of average people
Target audience
Anyone who is interested and open to new perspective regarding politics
We have noticed that many believe in the superiority of democracy as a political model. However, with "managed democracies" such as China slowly dominating the international scene, we have come to realize that managed democracies may prove to be a superior political model
Objectives
Showcase ideal democracy from another perspective, particularly to highlight its flaws
Decisions are only as good as the people who make them; a small group of elites can make decisions better than a large group of average people
Target audience
Anyone who is interested and open to new perspective regarding politics
Research: Ideal democracy vs Managed democracy
True democracy VS False democracy
A political system using a "true" democracy, like the USA, is one that gives all citizens an equal right to decide the affairs of the government. Each vote has an equal weight, and the people are able to pick, based on majority, what they want for the nation. This system represents the majority only, decisions will be based on the largest number of peoples interests. The elections are fair and allow equal chances for each party and candidate.
Democracy strives to achieve justice and fairness using this system, as instead of policies being dictated by a representative, the citizens have the privilege to decide for themselves, for the good of the greatest amount of people. Thus the government is restricted by the people, as when they lack support, nothing substantial can be done, and few bad decisions to the eyes of the people will be made. However, the drawbacks of this system is that the decisions the nation makes, will only be as good as the majority, as the most people will have the same idea. For example, if a politician has a brilliant idea, the people may not see the situation as he does, and quite possibly reject the idea. In this system, it will be hard to improve and push through innovative ideas for the good of the country because of the focus on the support and the voting of the people.
Another downside of a democracy is the Tyranny of the Majority. This happens when the majority of the population take advantage of the system using their numerical advantage to create policies unfair to the minority groups. One such example of this happening in the United States itself is in the 19th century, where the African Americans were taken advantage of. As most Americans in the slave era were white and free, they were the majority, and thus used their power to keep slavery from being abolished by the minorities. The government using this system is unable to intervene and with this absence of governmental protection, caused much misery to the blacks. The majority wields plenty of power in democracies, and the elite at the top may be restricted by it.
On the other hand, we feel that although Singapore officially has the same system as the USA, a democracy, it is a "false" democracy, as it seems to be a one party system, with the PAP dominating the elections with little to no contest. Although all the eligible population vote, and there are other opposing parties, their chances of winning are minimal. Almost all elections are won by a landslide victory, because the large majority of people have almost complete faith and trust in our government. Many are content with this system, and do not worry about the lack of opposition the PAP face, and believe that they will act for the good of the country. This form of democracy is backed by ancient philosophers such as Socrates and Plato, and also could be called benevolent dictatorship or soft authoritarianism. This false democracy in Singapore gives much power to the PAP, and thus allows efficient governance, as they have little opposition.
One benefit of this system in Singapore was shown through the introduction of the casino in Marina Bay Sands. Although the general population voiced much concern about the casino, the government remained unfazed and continued with this plan, which would be almost impossible in a democracy. Now, at least from an economic point of view, the casino has brought in 6.4 billlion dollars in 2011 alone, and has boosted Singapore's economy significantly. However, in this false democracy, there are also some inevitable issues. Singapore is fortunate to have a capable and clever government, with integrity, thus coupled with the faith and support of the people, created a prosperous nation in a short time span.
Our form of democracy is risky as once the leaders are corrupt and incompetent, the decisions backed by the population will turn out poorer and poorer, eventually leading this nation to its doom. Thus the system is risky and heavily dependent on the individuals running the country, and could swing the success of the nation both ways. In comparison, the democracy in the USA is a safer method, as the government will face intense opposition to a poor idea.
A political system using a "true" democracy, like the USA, is one that gives all citizens an equal right to decide the affairs of the government. Each vote has an equal weight, and the people are able to pick, based on majority, what they want for the nation. This system represents the majority only, decisions will be based on the largest number of peoples interests. The elections are fair and allow equal chances for each party and candidate.
Democracy strives to achieve justice and fairness using this system, as instead of policies being dictated by a representative, the citizens have the privilege to decide for themselves, for the good of the greatest amount of people. Thus the government is restricted by the people, as when they lack support, nothing substantial can be done, and few bad decisions to the eyes of the people will be made. However, the drawbacks of this system is that the decisions the nation makes, will only be as good as the majority, as the most people will have the same idea. For example, if a politician has a brilliant idea, the people may not see the situation as he does, and quite possibly reject the idea. In this system, it will be hard to improve and push through innovative ideas for the good of the country because of the focus on the support and the voting of the people.
Another downside of a democracy is the Tyranny of the Majority. This happens when the majority of the population take advantage of the system using their numerical advantage to create policies unfair to the minority groups. One such example of this happening in the United States itself is in the 19th century, where the African Americans were taken advantage of. As most Americans in the slave era were white and free, they were the majority, and thus used their power to keep slavery from being abolished by the minorities. The government using this system is unable to intervene and with this absence of governmental protection, caused much misery to the blacks. The majority wields plenty of power in democracies, and the elite at the top may be restricted by it.
On the other hand, we feel that although Singapore officially has the same system as the USA, a democracy, it is a "false" democracy, as it seems to be a one party system, with the PAP dominating the elections with little to no contest. Although all the eligible population vote, and there are other opposing parties, their chances of winning are minimal. Almost all elections are won by a landslide victory, because the large majority of people have almost complete faith and trust in our government. Many are content with this system, and do not worry about the lack of opposition the PAP face, and believe that they will act for the good of the country. This form of democracy is backed by ancient philosophers such as Socrates and Plato, and also could be called benevolent dictatorship or soft authoritarianism. This false democracy in Singapore gives much power to the PAP, and thus allows efficient governance, as they have little opposition.
One benefit of this system in Singapore was shown through the introduction of the casino in Marina Bay Sands. Although the general population voiced much concern about the casino, the government remained unfazed and continued with this plan, which would be almost impossible in a democracy. Now, at least from an economic point of view, the casino has brought in 6.4 billlion dollars in 2011 alone, and has boosted Singapore's economy significantly. However, in this false democracy, there are also some inevitable issues. Singapore is fortunate to have a capable and clever government, with integrity, thus coupled with the faith and support of the people, created a prosperous nation in a short time span.
Our form of democracy is risky as once the leaders are corrupt and incompetent, the decisions backed by the population will turn out poorer and poorer, eventually leading this nation to its doom. Thus the system is risky and heavily dependent on the individuals running the country, and could swing the success of the nation both ways. In comparison, the democracy in the USA is a safer method, as the government will face intense opposition to a poor idea.
Research: Sight vs Hearing
WHY IS SIGHT THE MOST IMPORTANT SENSE?
Of the five senses, sight is usually seen as the most important. Indeed, it is used in learning, moving about, entertainment and many more. Even hearing’s original territory in instantaneous communication is threatened by the rise of social media and texting. Throughout history, sight has always been important for survival and advancement. Why is this so? For starters, sight accounts for roughly 80% of the information we receive. Sight also provides extreme detail over close to infinite distances.
By comparison, senses like touch and taste require direct contact, and smell is totally dependent on the direction of the wind and hence is unreliable. Hearing travels much further than any of the aforementioned three, yet it still falls short of sight, which allows us to see even the stars billions of light years away. The distance over which sight works provides a way for humans to detect danger or food sources from long distances away; this is undeniably a plus for survival. Another factor to take into consideration is the speed at which the information can be perceived. From a distance, only sight, hearing and smell are viable means of perception. Smell takes some time to drift from the source to the target, while hearing is much faster at three hundred meters per second. However, sight easily takes the cake with practically instantaneous perception. This becomes useful when escaping from predators or fighting with others.
One final reason for sight’s importance is lesser known, that sight easily detects stationary objects. One may not agree that this is a factor in sight’s prominence, but we have to consider that the only advantage humans have over other animals is intelligence and information. Having said that, storage of information is paramount in the advance of civilization. In ancient times, the most convenient way to store and retrieve information was by writing and reading, since writing lasts hundreds of years (if not indefinitely) and was not difficult to execute. Reading too is simple and does not affect the medium itself, so information can be retrieved as many times as necessary. In comparison, sounds are much harder to store due to their dynamic nature and tastes and smells hardly last as long. Touch is actually viable in information storage, but did not become as prominent because of the proximity issues. Due to the (not necessarily evolutionary) obvious advantages offered by sight, it quickly became the “working sense” of humans just as English is the working language of the world.
To sum up:
1. Sight accounts for 80% of information received
2. Sight provides extreme detail
3. Sight works over long distances
4. Sight is instantaneous
5. Sight allows for easy storage and retrieval of information
HEARING
In the story we plan to write, hearing takes precedence over sight as the main sense of the cave-dwelling group of humans out of pure necessity. However this proves to be a workable system as hearing offers a few advantages of its own that match those of sight. Furthermore, there is empirical evidence that people can live with hearing alone.
Firstly, hearing does not discriminate spatially. One does not need to face the direction of the sound being made to tell what it is, how loud it is, or where it comes from. Sounds can be heard from any direction, making it more efficient in terms of perceiving the surroundings as a whole. Furthermore, sound does not need to travel in a straight line as light does. A person will be able to hear a loudspeaker behind a rock, even though he does not see it. Furthermore, sound can travel through the most irregular of passages, as well as through certain media and still be heard. This gives hearing a certain versatility that sight sorely lacks.
Additionally, sounds can overlap without obscuring one another, so it is very possible to hear more than one thing at the same time. To be fair, sight allows this as well, but there seems to be a limit on how many things a person can pay visual attention to at once, due to the sheer amount of concentration needed to process the massive amount of information perceived by sight, as well as the physical restrictions of perceiving many things with a fovea that occupies less than 1% of the total visual area one sees. (Note: the fovea refers to a small region of sight that provides the sharpest, most sensitive vision, while peripheral accounts for the blurrier, larger field of view we have). Hearing lets humans perceive everything at the same time, so an event of greater significance than the current task can be detected and focused on, for example, perception of the arrival of a predator takes precedence over perception of say, music.
Finally, the sense of sight is very limited by brightness. To see something, it must be a source of light or reflect light. The most objects in the environment do not produce light, so they must reflect it, and that requires a light source. Humans cannot produce light (although it would be interesting if they could), and so they rely on the sun to see everything. It would be perfect if the sun was always available, but there is night, and light can be blocked, so vision is not always available as a means of perception. However, hearing does not have this problem, as almost everything that moves makes noise, and those that do not can be echolocated with a human’s voice.
It is not impossible to navigate one’s way by hearing alone. Echolocation is a technique used by certain animals such as bats and dolphins, and surprisingly enough is extremely accurate, with bats being able to detect even the smallest of insects with great precision. Surprisingly enough, humans are capable of this too. Enter James Holman, the “blind traveler”. Using human echolocation, he managed to navigate across the world, which in the day was a feat even people with the ability to see had trouble achieving. (http://www.gutenberg.org/ebooks/12528,) Another notable example is the completely blind Ben Underwood, who uses clicking (with his tongue) to find his way around, ride bicycles and play video games ( http://www.benunderwood.com/index.html).
In conclusion, hearing does provide some advantages that sight does not, and humans are indeed versatile enough to use hearing to find their way around their surroundings. The question is, if there was a simple way to store information audibly, would the main sense of humans now be hearing?
Of the five senses, sight is usually seen as the most important. Indeed, it is used in learning, moving about, entertainment and many more. Even hearing’s original territory in instantaneous communication is threatened by the rise of social media and texting. Throughout history, sight has always been important for survival and advancement. Why is this so? For starters, sight accounts for roughly 80% of the information we receive. Sight also provides extreme detail over close to infinite distances.
By comparison, senses like touch and taste require direct contact, and smell is totally dependent on the direction of the wind and hence is unreliable. Hearing travels much further than any of the aforementioned three, yet it still falls short of sight, which allows us to see even the stars billions of light years away. The distance over which sight works provides a way for humans to detect danger or food sources from long distances away; this is undeniably a plus for survival. Another factor to take into consideration is the speed at which the information can be perceived. From a distance, only sight, hearing and smell are viable means of perception. Smell takes some time to drift from the source to the target, while hearing is much faster at three hundred meters per second. However, sight easily takes the cake with practically instantaneous perception. This becomes useful when escaping from predators or fighting with others.
One final reason for sight’s importance is lesser known, that sight easily detects stationary objects. One may not agree that this is a factor in sight’s prominence, but we have to consider that the only advantage humans have over other animals is intelligence and information. Having said that, storage of information is paramount in the advance of civilization. In ancient times, the most convenient way to store and retrieve information was by writing and reading, since writing lasts hundreds of years (if not indefinitely) and was not difficult to execute. Reading too is simple and does not affect the medium itself, so information can be retrieved as many times as necessary. In comparison, sounds are much harder to store due to their dynamic nature and tastes and smells hardly last as long. Touch is actually viable in information storage, but did not become as prominent because of the proximity issues. Due to the (not necessarily evolutionary) obvious advantages offered by sight, it quickly became the “working sense” of humans just as English is the working language of the world.
To sum up:
1. Sight accounts for 80% of information received
2. Sight provides extreme detail
3. Sight works over long distances
4. Sight is instantaneous
5. Sight allows for easy storage and retrieval of information
HEARING
In the story we plan to write, hearing takes precedence over sight as the main sense of the cave-dwelling group of humans out of pure necessity. However this proves to be a workable system as hearing offers a few advantages of its own that match those of sight. Furthermore, there is empirical evidence that people can live with hearing alone.
Firstly, hearing does not discriminate spatially. One does not need to face the direction of the sound being made to tell what it is, how loud it is, or where it comes from. Sounds can be heard from any direction, making it more efficient in terms of perceiving the surroundings as a whole. Furthermore, sound does not need to travel in a straight line as light does. A person will be able to hear a loudspeaker behind a rock, even though he does not see it. Furthermore, sound can travel through the most irregular of passages, as well as through certain media and still be heard. This gives hearing a certain versatility that sight sorely lacks.
Additionally, sounds can overlap without obscuring one another, so it is very possible to hear more than one thing at the same time. To be fair, sight allows this as well, but there seems to be a limit on how many things a person can pay visual attention to at once, due to the sheer amount of concentration needed to process the massive amount of information perceived by sight, as well as the physical restrictions of perceiving many things with a fovea that occupies less than 1% of the total visual area one sees. (Note: the fovea refers to a small region of sight that provides the sharpest, most sensitive vision, while peripheral accounts for the blurrier, larger field of view we have). Hearing lets humans perceive everything at the same time, so an event of greater significance than the current task can be detected and focused on, for example, perception of the arrival of a predator takes precedence over perception of say, music.
Finally, the sense of sight is very limited by brightness. To see something, it must be a source of light or reflect light. The most objects in the environment do not produce light, so they must reflect it, and that requires a light source. Humans cannot produce light (although it would be interesting if they could), and so they rely on the sun to see everything. It would be perfect if the sun was always available, but there is night, and light can be blocked, so vision is not always available as a means of perception. However, hearing does not have this problem, as almost everything that moves makes noise, and those that do not can be echolocated with a human’s voice.
It is not impossible to navigate one’s way by hearing alone. Echolocation is a technique used by certain animals such as bats and dolphins, and surprisingly enough is extremely accurate, with bats being able to detect even the smallest of insects with great precision. Surprisingly enough, humans are capable of this too. Enter James Holman, the “blind traveler”. Using human echolocation, he managed to navigate across the world, which in the day was a feat even people with the ability to see had trouble achieving. (http://www.gutenberg.org/ebooks/12528,) Another notable example is the completely blind Ben Underwood, who uses clicking (with his tongue) to find his way around, ride bicycles and play video games ( http://www.benunderwood.com/index.html).
In conclusion, hearing does provide some advantages that sight does not, and humans are indeed versatile enough to use hearing to find their way around their surroundings. The question is, if there was a simple way to store information audibly, would the main sense of humans now be hearing?
Rationale
THE RATIONALE FOR OUR PROJECT
5 questions for our project:
1. Why use e-book?
2. Why democracy vs. false democracy?
3. Why write a satire?
4. Why compare sight and hearing?
5. Why is the language different?
1. We decided on putting our project on the e-book platform because the main focus is satire. Satire is not restricted to the literary realm alone, it is also present in drawings and photographs (political cartoons), multimedia (the Simpsons), audio recordings (Mr. Brown) and many others. Hence e-books suit our project well as all these things can be integrated into a single resource.
2. We noticed that there is an underlying assumption that democracy is the best and most effective political system; however, this may not be the case. Democracy represents the will of the majority. This means two things, the first being that the minority is ignored, the second being that the decisions made are only as good as the majority of the population are. Thus, there is a group of people that may know what the majority needs even better than the majority themselves, and these people cannot make much of an impact in democracy. However, false democracy allows these people to flourish and make proper decisions for the country that are much better than what democracy can ever accomplish. On the other hand, should a corrupt government rise to power, the nation would be even worse off than in a democracy.
3. A satire is a way of criticizing certain ideas or people in an indirect way. In our case, we want to bring forward the view that democracy is not the only viable option; hence it is suitable to express this view in the form of a satire.
4. The comparison of sight and hearing is meant to parallel that of democracy and false democracy respectively. The idea is that sight and hearing are both equally viable as means of perception; this also applies to the viability of both democracy and false democracy as working political systems. However, the long range of view for sight parallels the consistency of democracy in terms of quality of choices made, while the versatility of hearing may also be similar to the flexibility of a false democracy. In any case, sight and hearing seem to be a suitable analogy to democracy and false democracy, so we will find more parallels in future.
5. The difference in language is here for two reasons. The first is purely logical. As language will be made up of whatever a person experiences, naturally hearing-inclined people build a different language from seeing-inclined people. This manifests itself in a complete absence of metaphors that have anything to do with sight, colour, brightness, etc, while more will be about pitch, timbre, loudness, etc. The second reason is that the concept of a hearing-based race of humans is extremely foreign to most, so while readers feel this distance on a conceptual level, they also feel it on a literary level, thus accentuating the differences between these people and humans.
5 questions for our project:
1. Why use e-book?
2. Why democracy vs. false democracy?
3. Why write a satire?
4. Why compare sight and hearing?
5. Why is the language different?
1. We decided on putting our project on the e-book platform because the main focus is satire. Satire is not restricted to the literary realm alone, it is also present in drawings and photographs (political cartoons), multimedia (the Simpsons), audio recordings (Mr. Brown) and many others. Hence e-books suit our project well as all these things can be integrated into a single resource.
2. We noticed that there is an underlying assumption that democracy is the best and most effective political system; however, this may not be the case. Democracy represents the will of the majority. This means two things, the first being that the minority is ignored, the second being that the decisions made are only as good as the majority of the population are. Thus, there is a group of people that may know what the majority needs even better than the majority themselves, and these people cannot make much of an impact in democracy. However, false democracy allows these people to flourish and make proper decisions for the country that are much better than what democracy can ever accomplish. On the other hand, should a corrupt government rise to power, the nation would be even worse off than in a democracy.
3. A satire is a way of criticizing certain ideas or people in an indirect way. In our case, we want to bring forward the view that democracy is not the only viable option; hence it is suitable to express this view in the form of a satire.
4. The comparison of sight and hearing is meant to parallel that of democracy and false democracy respectively. The idea is that sight and hearing are both equally viable as means of perception; this also applies to the viability of both democracy and false democracy as working political systems. However, the long range of view for sight parallels the consistency of democracy in terms of quality of choices made, while the versatility of hearing may also be similar to the flexibility of a false democracy. In any case, sight and hearing seem to be a suitable analogy to democracy and false democracy, so we will find more parallels in future.
5. The difference in language is here for two reasons. The first is purely logical. As language will be made up of whatever a person experiences, naturally hearing-inclined people build a different language from seeing-inclined people. This manifests itself in a complete absence of metaphors that have anything to do with sight, colour, brightness, etc, while more will be about pitch, timbre, loudness, etc. The second reason is that the concept of a hearing-based race of humans is extremely foreign to most, so while readers feel this distance on a conceptual level, they also feel it on a literary level, thus accentuating the differences between these people and humans.
Book reviews
BOOK REVIEWS OF POLITICAL SATIRES
A Clockwork Orange: Anthony Burgess’s “A Clockwork Orange” is a very dark and morbidly interesting piece of work that describes the experiences of a violent teenager under a totalitarian government. In this political satire, a few themes of the follies of politics are exposed. Firstly, the motive behind the pioneering of the Ludovico technique to rehabilitate prisoners was not for the prisoners’ well-being per se, but rather to make room for the government’s political adversaries. Secondly, we see that gangs rampage freely in the world, the only thing that convinces the government to change this is the fact that elections are coming up, so they attempt to resolve this by employing the offenders as millicents (policemen), an obvious recipe for disaster. Thirdly, the novel reinforces the fact that Alex is just a political tool, a theme emphasized by the name itself, clockwork orange (orange drawing its roots from the Malay word orang, man). The book criticizes even the political opponents of the government, as they too treat Alex as a tool, even getting him to jump off a building for the effect. Hence, we see clearly the follies of the government and politicians in general by what they did in the story. (199 words)
Brave New World: Brave New World is a futuristic novel about a “utopia” in the form of a world where everyone is happy and healthy, where there are no diseases or poverty. The entire novel is centered around the trade-off between freedom and happiness, and how science has been taken so far that humans are domesticated by it. Brave New World is not so much a political satire as it is a social one; nevertheless there are some elements of politics that the novel criticizes. The novel warns against taking a benevolent dictatorship too far, where even leaders are blatantly called controllers. Yet, no one seems to mind, because they are so infantile from a lifelong history of conditioning, both physical and mental, that they only desire to achieve happiness, nothing more. Perhaps the book cautions citizens to be wary of what the government is doing, and not be so lost in the pursuit of happiness that they become nothing more than gurgling babies intellectually. The book also condemns taking Fordism too far until everything is mass-produced and mass-consumed, which too destroys individuality. (180 words)
A Clockwork Orange: Anthony Burgess’s “A Clockwork Orange” is a very dark and morbidly interesting piece of work that describes the experiences of a violent teenager under a totalitarian government. In this political satire, a few themes of the follies of politics are exposed. Firstly, the motive behind the pioneering of the Ludovico technique to rehabilitate prisoners was not for the prisoners’ well-being per se, but rather to make room for the government’s political adversaries. Secondly, we see that gangs rampage freely in the world, the only thing that convinces the government to change this is the fact that elections are coming up, so they attempt to resolve this by employing the offenders as millicents (policemen), an obvious recipe for disaster. Thirdly, the novel reinforces the fact that Alex is just a political tool, a theme emphasized by the name itself, clockwork orange (orange drawing its roots from the Malay word orang, man). The book criticizes even the political opponents of the government, as they too treat Alex as a tool, even getting him to jump off a building for the effect. Hence, we see clearly the follies of the government and politicians in general by what they did in the story. (199 words)
Brave New World: Brave New World is a futuristic novel about a “utopia” in the form of a world where everyone is happy and healthy, where there are no diseases or poverty. The entire novel is centered around the trade-off between freedom and happiness, and how science has been taken so far that humans are domesticated by it. Brave New World is not so much a political satire as it is a social one; nevertheless there are some elements of politics that the novel criticizes. The novel warns against taking a benevolent dictatorship too far, where even leaders are blatantly called controllers. Yet, no one seems to mind, because they are so infantile from a lifelong history of conditioning, both physical and mental, that they only desire to achieve happiness, nothing more. Perhaps the book cautions citizens to be wary of what the government is doing, and not be so lost in the pursuit of happiness that they become nothing more than gurgling babies intellectually. The book also condemns taking Fordism too far until everything is mass-produced and mass-consumed, which too destroys individuality. (180 words)
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)
