Wednesday, July 4, 2012

Research: Sight vs Hearing

WHY IS SIGHT THE MOST IMPORTANT SENSE?

Of the five senses, sight is usually seen as the most important. Indeed, it is used in learning, moving about, entertainment and many more. Even hearing’s original territory in instantaneous communication is threatened by the rise of social media and texting. Throughout history, sight has always been important for survival and advancement. Why is this so? For starters, sight accounts for roughly 80% of the information we receive. Sight also provides extreme detail over close to infinite distances.

By comparison, senses like touch and taste require direct contact, and smell is totally dependent on the direction of the wind and hence is unreliable. Hearing travels much further than any of the aforementioned three, yet it still falls short of sight, which allows us to see even the stars billions of light years away. The distance over which sight works provides a way for humans to detect danger or food sources from long distances away; this is undeniably a plus for survival. Another factor to take into consideration is the speed at which the information can be perceived. From a distance, only sight, hearing and smell are viable means of perception. Smell takes some time to drift from the source to the target, while hearing is much faster at three hundred meters per second. However, sight easily takes the cake with practically instantaneous perception. This becomes useful when escaping from predators or fighting with others.

One final reason for sight’s importance is lesser known, that sight easily detects stationary objects. One may not agree that this is a factor in sight’s prominence, but we have to consider that the only advantage humans have over other animals is intelligence and information. Having said that, storage of information is paramount in the advance of civilization. In ancient times, the most convenient way to store and retrieve information was by writing and reading, since writing lasts hundreds of years (if not indefinitely) and was not difficult to execute. Reading too is simple and does not affect the medium itself, so information can be retrieved as many times as necessary. In comparison, sounds are much harder to store due to their dynamic nature and tastes and smells hardly last as long. Touch is actually viable in information storage, but did not become as prominent because of the proximity issues. Due to the (not necessarily evolutionary) obvious advantages offered by sight, it quickly became the “working sense” of humans just as English is the working language of the world.

To sum up:
1. Sight accounts for 80% of information received
2. Sight provides extreme detail
3. Sight works over long distances
4. Sight is instantaneous
5. Sight allows for easy storage and retrieval of information

HEARING

In the story we plan to write, hearing takes precedence over sight as the main sense of the cave-dwelling group of humans out of pure necessity. However this proves to be a workable system as hearing offers a few advantages of its own that match those of sight. Furthermore, there is empirical evidence that people can live with hearing alone.

Firstly, hearing does not discriminate spatially. One does not need to face the direction of the sound being made to tell what it is, how loud it is, or where it comes from. Sounds can be heard from any direction, making it more efficient in terms of perceiving the surroundings as a whole. Furthermore, sound does not need to travel in a straight line as light does. A person will be able to hear a loudspeaker behind a rock, even though he does not see it. Furthermore, sound can travel through the most irregular of passages, as well as through certain media and still be heard. This gives hearing a certain versatility that sight sorely lacks.

Additionally, sounds can overlap without obscuring one another, so it is very possible to hear more than one thing at the same time. To be fair, sight allows this as well, but there seems to be a limit on how many things a person can pay visual attention to at once, due to the sheer amount of concentration needed to process the massive amount of information perceived by sight, as well as the physical restrictions of perceiving many things with a fovea that occupies less than 1% of the total visual area one sees. (Note: the fovea refers to a small region of sight that provides the sharpest, most sensitive vision, while peripheral accounts for the blurrier, larger field of view we have). Hearing lets humans perceive everything at the same time, so an event of greater significance than the current task can be detected and focused on, for example, perception of the arrival of a predator takes precedence over perception of say, music.

Finally, the sense of sight is very limited by brightness. To see something, it must be a source of light or reflect light. The most objects in the environment do not produce light, so they must reflect it, and that requires a light source. Humans cannot produce light (although it would be interesting if they could), and so they rely on the sun to see everything. It would be perfect if the sun was always available, but there is night, and light can be blocked, so vision is not always available as a means of perception. However, hearing does not have this problem, as almost everything that moves makes noise, and those that do not can be echolocated with a human’s voice.

It is not impossible to navigate one’s way by hearing alone. Echolocation is a technique used by certain animals such as bats and dolphins, and surprisingly enough is extremely accurate, with bats being able to detect even the smallest of insects with great precision. Surprisingly enough, humans are capable of this too. Enter James Holman, the “blind traveler”. Using human echolocation, he managed to navigate across the world, which in the day was a feat even people with the ability to see had trouble achieving. (http://www.gutenberg.org/ebooks/12528,) Another notable example is the completely blind Ben Underwood, who uses clicking (with his tongue) to find his way around, ride bicycles and play video games ( http://www.benunderwood.com/index.html).

In conclusion, hearing does provide some advantages that sight does not, and humans are indeed versatile enough to use hearing to find their way around their surroundings. The question is, if there was a simple way to store information audibly, would the main sense of humans now be hearing?

No comments:

Post a Comment