True democracy VS False democracy
A political system using a "true" democracy, like the USA, is one that gives all citizens an equal right to decide the affairs of the government. Each vote has an equal weight, and the people are able to pick, based on majority, what they want for the nation. This system represents the majority only, decisions will be based on the largest number of peoples interests. The elections are fair and allow equal chances for each party and candidate.
Democracy strives to achieve justice and fairness using this system, as instead of policies being dictated by a representative, the citizens have the privilege to decide for themselves, for the good of the greatest amount of people. Thus the government is restricted by the people, as when they lack support, nothing substantial can be done, and few bad decisions to the eyes of the people will be made. However, the drawbacks of this system is that the decisions the nation makes, will only be as good as the majority, as the most people will have the same idea. For example, if a politician has a brilliant idea, the people may not see the situation as he does, and quite possibly reject the idea. In this system, it will be hard to improve and push through innovative ideas for the good of the country because of the focus on the support and the voting of the people.
Another downside of a democracy is the Tyranny of the Majority. This happens when the majority of the population take advantage of the system using their numerical advantage to create policies unfair to the minority groups. One such example of this happening in the United States itself is in the 19th century, where the African Americans were taken advantage of. As most Americans in the slave era were white and free, they were the majority, and thus used their power to keep slavery from being abolished by the minorities. The government using this system is unable to intervene and with this absence of governmental protection, caused much misery to the blacks. The majority wields plenty of power in democracies, and the elite at the top may be restricted by it.
On the other hand, we feel that although Singapore officially has the same system as the USA, a democracy, it is a "false" democracy, as it seems to be a one party system, with the PAP dominating the elections with little to no contest. Although all the eligible population vote, and there are other opposing parties, their chances of winning are minimal. Almost all elections are won by a landslide victory, because the large majority of people have almost complete faith and trust in our government. Many are content with this system, and do not worry about the lack of opposition the PAP face, and believe that they will act for the good of the country. This form of democracy is backed by ancient philosophers such as Socrates and Plato, and also could be called benevolent dictatorship or soft authoritarianism. This false democracy in Singapore gives much power to the PAP, and thus allows efficient governance, as they have little opposition.
One benefit of this system in Singapore was shown through the introduction of the casino in Marina Bay Sands. Although the general population voiced much concern about the casino, the government remained unfazed and continued with this plan, which would be almost impossible in a democracy. Now, at least from an economic point of view, the casino has brought in 6.4 billlion dollars in 2011 alone, and has boosted Singapore's economy significantly. However, in this false democracy, there are also some inevitable issues. Singapore is fortunate to have a capable and clever government, with integrity, thus coupled with the faith and support of the people, created a prosperous nation in a short time span.
Our form of democracy is risky as once the leaders are corrupt and incompetent, the decisions backed by the population will turn out poorer and poorer, eventually leading this nation to its doom. Thus the system is risky and heavily dependent on the individuals running the country, and could swing the success of the nation both ways. In comparison, the democracy in the USA is a safer method, as the government will face intense opposition to a poor idea.
No comments:
Post a Comment