Wednesday, July 4, 2012

Rationale

THE RATIONALE FOR OUR PROJECT

5 questions for our project:

1. Why use e-book?
2. Why democracy vs. false democracy?
3. Why write a satire?
4. Why compare sight and hearing?
5. Why is the language different?

1. We decided on putting our project on the e-book platform because the main focus is satire. Satire is not restricted to the literary realm alone, it is also present in drawings and photographs (political cartoons), multimedia (the Simpsons), audio recordings (Mr. Brown) and many others. Hence e-books suit our project well as all these things can be integrated into a single resource.

2. We noticed that there is an underlying assumption that democracy is the best and most effective political system; however, this may not be the case. Democracy represents the will of the majority. This means two things, the first being that the minority is ignored, the second being that the decisions made are only as good as the majority of the population are. Thus, there is a group of people that may know what the majority needs even better than the majority themselves, and these people cannot make much of an impact in democracy. However, false democracy allows these people to flourish and make proper decisions for the country that are much better than what democracy can ever accomplish. On the other hand, should a corrupt government rise to power, the nation would be even worse off than in a democracy.

3. A satire is a way of criticizing certain ideas or people in an indirect way. In our case, we want to bring forward the view that democracy is not the only viable option; hence it is suitable to express this view in the form of a satire.

4. The comparison of sight and hearing is meant to parallel that of democracy and false democracy respectively. The idea is that sight and hearing are both equally viable as means of perception; this also applies to the viability of both democracy and false democracy as working political systems. However, the long range of view for sight parallels the consistency of democracy in terms of quality of choices made, while the versatility of hearing may also be similar to the flexibility of a false democracy. In any case, sight and hearing seem to be a suitable analogy to democracy and false democracy, so we will find more parallels in future.

5. The difference in language is here for two reasons. The first is purely logical. As language will be made up of whatever a person experiences, naturally hearing-inclined people build a different language from seeing-inclined people. This manifests itself in a complete absence of metaphors that have anything to do with sight, colour, brightness, etc, while more will be about pitch, timbre, loudness, etc. The second reason is that the concept of a hearing-based race of humans is extremely foreign to most, so while readers feel this distance on a conceptual level, they also feel it on a literary level, thus accentuating the differences between these people and humans.

No comments:

Post a Comment